UNH

Outcome

—

Return

—

Status

—

Subscribe to read

Outcome

—

Return

—

Status

—

Subscribe to read

Outcome

✓

Return

+2.25%

Status

scored

Initiating UNH at Buy rating with 50% conviction sizing in two tranches: 25% at $371 with $361 hard stop (2.7% defined downside), and 25% deferred to post-Oct 13 Q3 earnings confirmation. The blended expected return is +2.1% with hard stops on both legs, capturing pre-earnings asymmetry while respecting the binding prior record of alpha bleeds on this exact pre-binary-catalyst setup.

Outcome

✗

Return

-1.34%

Status

scored

Maintain UNH exposure with mandatory put protection at $355-360 strike, November expiry, sized 1-1.5% of position. No active trim, no fresh long, no new short. The Hold-with-puts architecture is mandated because pre-binary-catalyst Underweights (10-01, 10-02) and unhedged Hold (10-05) have all documented as bleeding alpha on this exact setup. October 13 Q3 print is the hard reassessment event.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.09%

Status

scored

Maintain current UNH position at neutral weight with MANDATORY put protection at $355-360 strike (November expiry) — this Hold-with-puts architecture is the calibrated response per the 10-05 binding reflection, which explicitly forecloses both active trim and unhedged Hold as failure modes. The $24B TTM FCF floor and 0.62 defensive beta support a $352 structural support, while the Oct 13 Q3 print serves as the hard reassessment event with pre-committed triggers: upgrade to Overweight on clean beat above $390, cut to minimum weight on any miss or soft guide.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.60%

Status

scored

Maintain UNH at neutral weight with a stop at $360 daily close and $349.61 weekly close; Hold rather than trim ahead of the Oct 13 Q3 earnings print given two consecutive failed Underweights on this exact binary-catalyst setup and 86% Polymarket beat pricing that creates negative expected value on a simple beat. Optional put hedge at $360 strike November expiry for concentrated positions, with $352 (200 SMA) as the structural floor and $391 (50 SMA reclaim) as the bullish re-engagement trigger.

Outcome

✗

Return

+1.80%

Status

scored

Trim 15-20% of UNH at current spot (~$371.90) immediately rather than waiting for overhead resistance at $379-393, as the 50 SMA has been resistance for 10+ weeks and the trim zone is unlikely to print. Retain residual position with put protection at $360 strike, October expiry, with hard stops at $352.56 daily close (200 SMA structural floor) and $349.61 weekly close (full-exit trigger). Oct 13 Q3 earnings is the hard reassessment event with a pre-defined reentry plan committed in advance; the Underweight rating captures directional caution while preserving participation in any constructive resolution given the 2.54% dividend yield and re-rating optionality.

Outcome

✗

Return

+1.83%

Status

scored

Underweight rating issued for UNH based on confirmed downtrend (five lower highs in 75 days, MACD bearish non-divergence), structural margin compression (6.2% to 2.7%), and intact 50 SMA overhead resistance. Action plan calls for a 25-30% trim executed at current spot prices ($365-375) rather than anchoring to the $379-393 resistance zone, plus $360 strike October put protection for residual exposure—explicitly rejecting a new short position due to poor risk/reward at current levels with stop essentially at entry. Hard stop triggers are set at $351 daily close or $349.61 weekly close, with mandatory reassessment at October 13 Q3 earnings.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.51%

Status

scored

Analysts unanimously recommend HOLD on UNH at current 85-95% benchmark weight with two pre-committed buy triggers: (a) close above $375.15 10 EMA on volume ≥5M with MACD histogram flip positive, OR (b) flush to $352 that holds on weekly close with constructive MACD turn. The $352 200 SMA serves as hard structural backstop, with hard reassessment forced at Oct 13 Q3 earnings regardless of intervening price action.

Outcome

✗

Return

-2.10%

Status

scored

Maintain UNH at 85-95% of benchmark weight (Hold) with light defensive tilt through the Oct 13 Q3 earnings binary catalyst; do not trim toward the research manager's 50-75% Underweight or the trader's SELL as both overshoot per the 09-28 binding lesson on floor-protected pre-catalyst setups. Hard stop at $349.61 weekly close (200 SMA structural break), 3-5 trading day time-stop for forced recalibration, with re-engagement trigger at confirmed close above $397.39 on volume ≥5M with MACD bullish cross.

Outcome

–

Return

-0.76%

Status

scored

The decision recommends trimming 15-20% of the position at the current $376 spot price to achieve a ~4% portfolio weight, with a hard stop at $364 daily close (lower Bollinger Band) and full exit trigger at $349.61 weekly close (200 SMA structural break). The Underweight rating is based on 10 consecutive weeks of 50 SMA rejection at $396.48, negative tangible book value of -$31.9B, and delayed commercial margin recovery past 2027 not yet reflected in consensus EPS of $22.61, though the $24.3B TTM FCF floor and 0.62 defensive beta prevent a full Sell recommendation. The Oct 13 Q3 earnings serves as the binary reassessment catalyst for cost trend commentary toward 11% normalization and FY26 guide maintenance.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.33%

Status

scored

Maintain UNH at neutral weight with a hard stop at $350 daily close (200 SMA) and full-exit trigger at $349.61 weekly close; the 3-5 trading day time-stop forces reassessment before the Oct 13 Q3 binary catalyst, with new positions to wait for confirmed resolution above $397.39 (50 SMA reclaim on volume) or capitulation flush to $351. The simpler framework aligns with the 09-24 binding lesson that trim-alpha is structurally bounded near zero in this floor-protected, catalyst-pending setup.

Outcome

–

Return

+0.42%

Status

scored

The decision mandates a 20-25% trim of UNH to 75-80% benchmark weight, executing immediately at the current $371-375 spot rather than waiting for overhead resistance. A hard stop loss is set at $350 weekly close, with a compressed 3-5 trading day time-stop forcing active recalibration before alpha bleeds out through passive carry. Hard reassessment occurs at Oct 13 Q3 earnings, where cost trend commentary is prioritized over headline EPS for re-rating decisions.

Outcome

✗

Return

+1.00%

Status

scored

Maintain 75-80% of benchmark weight (trim 20-25% immediately) with hard stop at $350 weekly close and a 3-5 trading day time-stop; re-rating to Hold requires close above $386.73 with RSI >50 on ≥5M volume plus cost trend normalization toward 11%. Oct 13 Q3 earnings serves as the hard reassessment catalyst regardless of intervening action.

Outcome

–

Return

-0.45%

Status

scored

Trim 30-50% of existing long exposure into rallies at $386-$400 over 2 weeks, targeting 50-70% of benchmark weight; do not initiate new longs at $372 or go net short given the $350 200 SMA floor and 7.3% FCF yield as structural support. Hard reassessment at Oct 13 Q3 2026 earnings with a compressed 5-7 trading day time-stop; bear thesis invalidates on confirmed close above $405 on volume ≥5M with RSI >50.

Outcome

✓

Return

-1.22%

Status

scored

Maintain UNH at benchmark weight with active management discipline—the structural floor ($350) and binary Oct 13 Q3 catalyst warrant holding, but the 09-18 lesson that passive Hold twice produced negative alpha demands pre-committed execution parameters. Stop at $350 daily close, full exit if weekly closes below $349.61, trim on confirmed close above $382 on volume ≥5M with RSI >50, and a binding 10-trading-day time-stop forces recalibration.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.18%

Status

scored

Maintain UNH at neutral benchmark weight with tight active management. Do not add at current $376.90 (momentum has not turned); do not aggressively trim (franchise floor intact at $350.16 200 SMA with $24B+ TTM FCF, A-rated balance sheet, 2.47% dividend). Set $370 daily-close stop-loss, $349.61 weekly-close full-exit trigger, and 10-trading-day time-stop. Hard reassessment at Q3 2026 earnings mid-October.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.45%

Status

scored

UNH is neutralized to HOLD at benchmark weight, rejecting both the Trader's Sell and Research Manager's Underweight proposals. The decision applies the binding 09-16 lesson, which explicitly directs neutralizing to Hold when the structural floor holds and SPY grinds higher through a binary catalyst window—maintaining directional Underweight has been alpha-destructive in this exact setup pattern. The active Hold incorporates a 15-day time-stop, $370 stop loss, conditional 15-20% trim trigger above $382 on confirmation, and a binding full-exit if weekly close breaks below $349.61.

Outcome

–

Return

-0.01%

Status

scored

Maintain UNH at 75-80% of benchmark weight (Underweight), overriding the current Hold consensus based on binding prior lessons from 09-14 and 09-15 that explicitly direct a 20-25% trim for this exact convergence pattern of technical breakdown and fundamental deterioration with intact structural backstop. The stop loss has been tightened to $362 (triggered at current price), with full exit triggered on weekly close below $349.61 (200 SMA), and hard reassessment scheduled for Q3 2026 earnings mid-October.

Outcome

✗

Return

-0.18%

Status

scored

Trim UNH 20-25% immediately to 75-80% residual (per 09-14 binding reflection), maintaining $375 hard stop and full-exit trigger at $349.61 weekly close. The 20-25% sizing sits outside documented failure zones—lighter than the 09-04 and trader proposals (preserving franchise optionality) and heavier than the 09-14 precedent (capturing alpha from concurrent technical and fundamental deterioration). Full Sell avoided given load-bearing franchise floor; residual positioned to capture Q3 earnings recovery if catalyst resolves bull or add further on bear confirmation.

Outcome

✓

Return

-1.99%

Status

scored

Underweight maintained with a 10-15% trim (leaving 85-90% residual) based on the binding 09-11 lesson directing lighter sizing than the prior 20-25% trim when technical breakdown coexists with intact franchise floor and binary catalysts weeks away; $375 hard stop preserved as the calibration between 200 SMA structural invalidation at $351.15 and current price, with hard reassessment at Q3 earnings mid-October and bull upgrade triggers at $408.33 with volume ≥5M and confirmed MACD/RSI confirmation.

Outcome

✗

Return

+1.18%

Status

scored

Trim UNH 20-25% immediately to 75-80% residual weight based on the binding 09-10 lesson, which showed that a pure Hold at benchmark weight produced -3.2% alpha in a structurally identical setup with declining 50 SMA, bearish MACD cross, and RSI in the mid-30s. Add $345-350 strike January 2027 protective puts at approximately 1.5-2% of residual notional as cheap tail insurance through the Q3 binary catalyst, while maintaining a $348 hard stop anchored to the 200 SMA structural support level.

Outcome

✗

Return

-2.37%

Status

scored

Maintain UNH at or below benchmark weight with active management rather than passive carry. Add modestly on confirmed close above $405 with 10 EMA reclaim; trim into rallies toward $400-$410. A binding 15-trading-day time-stop auto-downgrades to Underweight if price fails to break above $405 or below $385 within the window.

Outcome

✓

Return

-1.22%

Status

scored

Maintain UNH at neutral/Hold sizing with the trader's refined framework—do not add at current $393 levels as expected value is approximately $386 (roughly 2% negative). Asymmetric add zones are above $410 on confirmed momentum or at the $350-$360 200 SMA zone on weakness; treat $378 as a two-day close confirmation for risk reduction and downgrade to Underweight on weekly close below $350. Hard reassessment at Q3 2026 earnings mid-October with October 1 PA-removal as interim data point.

Outcome

✗

Return

-1.94%

Status

scored

UNH is maintained at Hold with existing exposure kept at core or benchmark weight but no additions above $400. The operating margin recovery from 0.34% (Q4 2025) to 8.05% (Q1 2026) and 7.13% (Q2 2026) supports preserving the position, but the roughly 1.5:1 payoff ratio from the $349.61 stop to $480 upside does not justify a Buy. New capital should wait for a pullback to $360-$380, a volume-confirmed close above $431, or a Q3 beat showing sequential margin expansion above 8.5% with raised FY2026 guidance.

Outcome

✗

Return

+0.93%

Status

scored

Trim 55-60% of the UNH position ahead of the Q3 2026 catalyst cluster, leaving 40-45% residual with a $345 hard stop on the residual and a collar hedge ($380 puts at ~25% notional) to define downside through the binary window (October 1 PA-removal implementation, Q3 earnings mid-October, potential buyback re-initiation). The exit from the alpha-destructive 40-50% residual zone documented in the 09-03 reflection is mandatory given the structural identity between current setup and the 09-02 binding lesson that flagged drift in no-man's-land as alpha-destructive.

Outcome

–

Return

-0.95%

Status

scored

Maintain a tactical Underweight on UNH by trimming 40-50% of the position into rallies toward $410-415 while retaining a 50-55% core residual through an imminent four-event catalyst cluster (Oct 1 prior-auth rollout, CMS Final Rate Notice, Q2 earnings mid-October, Q3 earnings late October/early November). Set the protective stop on residual at $380 closing basis (recovery thesis invalidation level), not $432, which would function as a trailing exit on the trim rather than downside risk protection. The $380 stop provides approximately $20/share of defined downside risk on the residual position, creating roughly 1:1 risk/reward against the $432 trim exit level. Reassess to Hold if UNH closes above $412 on volume ≥5M with MACD line crossing positive, or if Q3 EPS exceeds $5.50 with operating margin above 7.5% and benign MLR commentary.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.32%

Status

scored

Maintain UNH at benchmark weight with pre-committed decision rules: add up to 50% of incremental size on confirmed close above $412.50 with volume >5M and MACD expansion, with hard stop at $384.20 and $347.96 200 SMA as structural defense. The $384.20/$412.50 range represents balanced asymmetric payoff with Q3 2026 earnings in mid-October as the hard reassessment catalyst.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.85%

Status

scored

Analysts unanimously converged on Hold for UNH as the stock trades in no-man's-land between the $413 50 SMA reclaim trigger and the $384 hard stop. The $396 level offers negative risk/reward with the stock 4.1% below its 50 SMA but 14% above the rising 200 SMA, with MACD still negative at -5.23. Recommend preserving optionality via the $384 stop and optional $380 protective puts through the hard reassessment at Q3 2026 earnings mid-October.

Outcome

✗

Return

+1.77%

Status

scored

Reduce UNH to 50-55% of benchmark weight through staged execution around the Trump healthcare announcement catalyst, trimming 40-50% of the intended position before the event to neutralize gap risk with the balance executed based on outcome (add on benign result, trigger stop discipline on destructive). Stop loss at $370-372 closing basis on residual (~2 ATR) with $347 (200 SMA) as hard structural reassessment trigger; no protective puts as position sizing is the hedge and VIX-elevated premiums are overpriced. Single-trigger re-entry on 50 SMA reclaim with ≥5M volume and positive MACD, or Q2 MLR improvement, or buyback resumption disclosure.

Outcome

–

Return

-0.90%

Status

scored

Initiate Overweight on UNH at $392 with a 25% initial tranche, scaling to full position via a four-tranche structure (10% on $383-388 pullback, 35% on $345-355 200 SMA retest, 30% on confirmed breakout above $412-415 with volume ≥5M). Set stop at $345 closing-basis (~12% downside), with $380 strike puts at 25% of position notional as protection against the Q2 earnings binary in mid-July 2026.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.53%

Status

scored

Trim UNH from benchmark weight to a 5-7% portfolio cap over 1-2 weeks, staging 40-50% of execution before Jackson Hole and the balance after to neutralize event risk. Deploy a pre-committed collar (sell $430-440 calls to fund $370-380 puts at 25% of residual notional) to monetize elevated IV while defining downside; stop loss at $382 closing basis with hard reassessment at $346 (200 SMA). This is a 1-2 quarter tactical trim, not a structural downgrade—UNH remains on the high-quality watchlist for re-entry on a single confirmed catalyst.

Outcome

✗

Return

-1.49%

Status

scored

Maintain UNH at 3-5% of portfolio weight with no additions at current $401 level and no preemptive trimming. The HOLD is anchored to specific catalysts—Q2 earnings in late July 2026 (commercial MLR trajectory), October CMS Star Ratings, and ongoing IRS dispute monitoring—with hard reassessment at Q3 earnings mid-October. Entry triggers include breakout above $413.50 on 5M+ volume or capitulation flush below $383 with wash-out pattern; hard stop at $383 closing basis.

Outcome

✗

Return

+1.11%

Status

scored

Trim 15-20% of UNH at $393-396 while maintaining an 80-85% core position; employ a $382 closing-basis stop on the residual tranche and mandate a pre-committed Dec 2026 put spread covering 25% of the residual position sized to AEP-proximity (Q3 print mid-October), with re-entry tied to confirmable signals rather than predetermined price levels.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.54%

Status

scored

Maintain UNH at benchmark weight with no net new exposure at current levels. A tactical 25-33% scale-in is permitted only if three conditions trigger within 5 days: 3 consecutive closes above $396.55, RSI >50 on close, and up-day volume exceeding the 5-day average by 20%. Stop loss is set at $378 closing-basis with a hard reassessment trigger at $345.68, and any material IRS disclosure within 30-60 days requires cutting the position in half.

Outcome

✗

Return

+2.22%

Status

scored

Trim UNH 25-30% at current levels (~$390) or $395-400, with additional 15-20% trim queued at $405-410, reducing total exposure to 50-60% of benchmark weight. Deploy mandatory Dec 2026 $380-390 put spread at 25% of residual notional, pre-committed at decision time, with closing-basis intermediate stop at $382 and hard structural reassessment at $345 (200 SMA). Re-entry requires either reclaim of 50 SMA on volume with MACD positive cross, capitulation flush to $345-360 with volume climax, or Q3 2026 MLR normalization, with hard reassessment at Q3 print mid-October regardless of intervening signals.

Outcome

✗

Return

+1.37%

Status

scored

Trim UNH to 0.25-0.35x benchmark weight over 1-2 weeks using the $395-$405 strength zone as exit triggers rather than chasing weakness; maintain mandatory 25% residual put spread hedge (60-90 DTE) pre-committed at decision time per AEP-proximity sizing lesson. Stop converted to $368-$372 closing-basis (below lower Bollinger Band but actionable), with no new capital initiation. Re-enter only on two-condition test: technical repair (close above $397 on 5M+ volume with MACD/RSI improvement) or catalyst resolution (IRS audit range disclosed, governance lawsuit motion-to-dismiss, or MLR normalization in two consecutive prints). Q3 2026 earnings mid-October is hard reassessment regardless of intervening signals.

Outcome

–

Return

-0.97%

Status

scored

Trim UNH exposure by 20-25% to cap at 1.5% of portfolio, converting any remaining stop to a $370 closing-basis hard stop. Pre-commit a $400/$365 put spread at 25% of remaining residual with 60-90 DTE, as two consecutive Holds without hedges (2026-08-05 and 2026-08-12) destroyed -2.0% and -2.3% alpha respectively. Re-entry requires three-condition confirmation: close above $414 with 5M+ volume and positive MACD, flush to $360 with volume climax and higher low, or Q3 2026 earnings confirming MLR normalization.

Outcome

✗

Return

-1.35%

Status

scored

Maintain UNH position with no change in sizing; the $390 closing-basis stop is the thesis-breaking level for the existing position, with a close below on expanding volume warranting defensive trim or hedge deployment. For new capital, wait for confirmed close above 50 SMA at $414.83 with positive MACD crossover before considering incremental deployment.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.43%

Status

scored

Trim 40% of UNH position over 3-4 weeks using opportunistic strength toward $405-$415 as exit triggers, deploying a mandatory $400/$365 put spread hedge sized at 25% of residual per the AEP-proximity lesson; convert the $344 hard stop to a $380 closing-basis intermediate stop while retaining $344 as the hard structural reassessment trigger. Re-entry requires both technical repair (10-day EMA reclaim with improving MACD histogram and expanding volume) plus either medical cost trend normalization or meaningful lawsuit resolution disclosure, within a preferred $340-$360 zone near or below the 200-day SMA.

Outcome

✓

Return

-1.52%

Status

scored

Analysts unanimously recommend holding UNH with a mandatory $400/$365 put spread hedge (25% of residual, 60-90 DTE) pre-committed at decision time to avoid replicating the alpha-destroying pattern from 2026-08-05 and 2026-08-12. The $385 mental stop is converted to a closing-basis intermediate stop at $393.95 (lower Bollinger Band), with a hard structural exit at $375; the trader is instructed not to add on weakness and instead trim 20-25% into any rally at the $414-$427 resistance zone.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.67%

Status

scored

Three risk analysts from opposing frameworks converge on Hold for UNH — Conservative wins the structural bearish argument (MACD widening from -0.30 to -3.67, 17.79x P/E embeds 44% recovery requiring multiple tailwinds), Aggressive wins the recovery argument (Q1 2026 operating income $8.99B nearly matching prior year, 200 SMA support at $343.87 intact), and Neutral wins execution refinement (convert mental $388 stop to closing-basis $395.59 lower Bollinger, allow tactical 20-25% trim into $414-$427 resistance). The mandatory $400/$365 put spread hedge (25% of residual, 60-90 DTE) is the primary alpha source — prior Hold without pre-committed hedge destroyed -2.0% alpha while hedged Hold generated +1.5% alpha, establishing this as controlling instruction rather than optional insurance.

Outcome

✗

Return

-1.61%

Status

scored

Three risk analysts (aggressive, conservative, neutral) converge on Hold despite opposing conviction frameworks, establishing a robust central tendency. The mandatory $400/$365 put spread hedge (25% of residual, 60-90 DTE) is the load-bearing element distinguishing this Hold from the alpha-destroying 2026-08-05 pattern—failure to mechanically execute degrades the rating to Underweight. The trader's $398 mental stop converts to a hard closing-basis stop at $399.73; no addition at $405—await either a confirmed close above $413 on ≥5M volume or a pullback to $360-370.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.85%

Status

scored

UNH holds at $402 with a convergent all-analyst HOLD rating, trading at 17.9x forward P/E on $22.44 EPS with 2.27% dividend yield providing ballast while technicals test the lower Bollinger at $399.73; the mandatory $400/$365 put spread hedge (25% of residual, 60-90 DTE) is required per the 2026-08-05 lesson that optional hedges destroyed alpha on this exact setup, with add triggers at $413 close on ≥5M volume and second consecutive EPS ≥$6.50, base case target $420 over 12 months.

Outcome

✓

Return

-1.60%

Status

scored

Trim 30–40% of UNH exposure over 3–4 weeks while retaining a smaller core position, deploying a $400/$365 put spread hedge sized to 25% of the residual position (not maximum notional) per AEP-proximity lessons from 2026-08-06 and 2026-08-07, with an optional covered call monetization at $425–$430 strikes expiring after Q2 print. Convert the trader's $402 hard stop to a CLOSING basis stop at $402.24 (lower Bollinger Band) to filter routine volatility on a name with $11.64 ATR. Hard reassessment dated to Q3 2026 earnings (mid-October) regardless of intervening signals, with $400 price target and 3–6 month time horizon.

Outcome

–

Return

+0.41%

Status

scored

Trim 30–40% of UNH into the $413–$420 resistance zone, reduce target weight to 1.5–2.0% of equity portfolio, retain hedged residual as core defensive compounder. Underweight rating enforced by prior lesson pattern where passive Hold destroyed alpha twice in the last five sessions; mandatory $400/$365 put spread hedge (60–90 DTE, 25–33% of residual) required to neutralize mid-October Q3 2026 binary catalyst. Stop on residual at $397 close; hard exit below $385 on volume. Trim pacing calibrated to August 13 CPI print. Price target $400 over 3–6 months with hard reassessment at Q3 2026 print.

Outcome

–

Return

+0.77%

Status

scored

Trim 30–40% of UNH exposure at current levels as technical breakdown is confirmed below both the 10 EMA and 50 SMA with a textbook lower-high/lower-low sequence, while buybacks have been paused since H2 2025—suggesting even management doesn't view the stock as undervalued at $414. Retain a smaller core position with mandatory $400/$365 put spread hedge (60–90 DTE, 25–33% of residual) and re-enter either on recovery above $414.86 with MACD improvement or aggressively on capitulation flush to $385–$395.