HD

Outcome

—

Return

—

Status

—

Subscribe to read

Outcome

—

Return

—

Status

—

Subscribe to read

Outcome

✗

Return

-1.60%

Status

scored

Hold rating maintained for Home Depot with Stage 1 re-engagement (~13% of original position re-added at ~$295) following confirmed reversal trigger (price >10 EMA $287.95, RSI 45.81, volume 8.69M), while Stages 2/3 remain deferred until macro gates fire (50 SMA reclaim at $317, 200 SMA reclaim at $333, and Fed-cut probability >50% or rate relief confirmed); hard invalidation set at $270 with trailing stop to $295 once above $305, and mandatory reassessment within 5-10 trading days of Q3 FY2026 earnings mid-November.

Outcome

✗

Return

+3.39%

Status

scored

Maintain Hold rating on HD with a mechanical 40% trim executed at market (~280), capping residual at 1.0% portfolio with hard invalidation at 270. Reject Sell and Underweight labels despite correct bearish direction because six prior cycles show Hold architecture with trim produces -0.1% to +1.4% alpha versus -3.8% from Underweight and -2.0% from Sell. Reinvestment split 50/50 between non-housing equity and cash/T-bills; staged three-condition re-engagement framework requires both price and macro confirmation.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.32%

Status

scored

Hold maintained as the only architecture with positive alpha (+1.4% on 10/05) versus the four consecutive Underweight calls that bled -3.8% alpha and three Sell calls that bled -2.0% alpha. Execute a mechanical 1/3 trim at market (~280), cap residual at 1.5% of portfolio, set hard invalidation at 270 (close below on volume triggers mechanical exit), and require three of four re-engagement conditions before adding back — requiring price confirmation (>317 close with RSI >40 and volume), technical confirmation (50 SMA/200 SMA golden cross with MACD), macro confirmation (Fed-cut probability >50%), and rate confirmation (10Y below 4.5% or 30Y mortgages below 6.5% sustained 5+ sessions).

Outcome

✗

Return

+1.97%

Status

scored

The four consecutive Underweight calls on HD produced cumulative -3.8% alpha, while the single Hold produced -0.5% alpha—the best outcome in the cycle. The framework now defaults to Hold with the existing position, dividend capture, no new capital deployment, and a rule-based trim trigger at $277 (52-week low) with protective hedging and mandatory reassessment within 5-10 days of Q3 FY2026 earnings mid-November.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.60%

Status

scored

The portfolio manager affirms an UNDERWEIGHT rating on Home Depot, rejecting the trader's Sell proposal on execution architecture grounds—the $295 entry/$276 stop replicates the proven 9/30 failure mode. The binding decision mandates a 25-30% trim executed at market NOW at ~$282 rather than waiting for a rally, with a hard residual stop at $277.20 (lower Bollinger Band pierce) and preservation of 1.0-1.5% residual for dividend carry and defended-floor optionality. Re-evaluation is mandatory within 5-10 trading days of Q3 FY2026 earnings mid-November 2026, with a probability-weighted price target of $275.

Outcome

–

Return

+0.14%

Status

scored

Trim 25-30% of HD exposure at market now (~$282) rather than waiting for resistance fills, preserving a 1.0-1.5% residual with a hard stop at $277.20 (lower Bollinger Band). The Underweight architecture mechanically applies the 9/30 binding lesson: residual reduction must be automatic, not contingent on rallies that may not materialize. Reinvest 50% of proceeds into non-housing equity and 50% into cash or short-duration Treasuries yielding 4%+.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.71%

Status

scored

Underweight rating on HD with a 50-60% trim strategy targeting $295-300 resistance levels, retaining only 1.0-1.5% residual with a hard stop at $279. Proceeds split 50/50 between non-housing equity and cash/short-duration Treasuries yielding 4%+ to preserve optionality. Re-engagement requires two of four conditions including Fed-cut probability above 50%, 10Y below 4.5%, technical reclaim above $317 with RSI greater than 40, or 50 SMA/200 SMA golden cross with positive MACD. Price target $275 reflects 50% probability of continued grind to $260-275, 30% floor-bounce to $310-320, and 20% macro relief breakout to $335+. Mandatory reassessment within 5-10 trading days of Q3 FY26 earnings in mid-November 2026.

Outcome

–

Return

-1.23%

Status

scored

The bear thesis is directionally correct given deteriorating margins (Q3 FY26 operating margin 14.3%, down 20bps YoY), hostile macro conditions (96% no-cut probability, 7.58% mortgages, 10Y near 5%), and bearish technicals (death cross intact, RSI 28.94), but three prior HD Sell cycles produced cumulative -2.0% alpha due to HD's defensive carry characteristics, making Underweight with trim discipline superior to full exit; existing holders should trim 20-30% into $296-$300 resistance while maintaining 1.0-1.5% residual with hard stop at $285, and new tactical shorts require post-confirmation entry below $287.90 on high volume.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.64%

Status

scored

Home Depot receives a HOLD rating with unanimous analyst consensus for the first time in five cycles. Maintain current position sizing with a $270 hard stop and tactical-trim discipline (15-20%) into $314-$320 relief rallies, while requiring technical confirmation (50 SMA reclaim at $324.61 + RSI >40 + MACD positive cross + volume ≥3M shares) before considering adds. Re-evaluate within 5-10 trading days of Q3 FY2026 earnings mid-November, with price target of $300.00.

Outcome

✓

Return

-1.13%

Status

scored

Exit 100% of HD at market over 1-3 trading sessions with no contingent trim triggers or wait-for-rally execution—the binding lesson from four prior HD cycles demonstrates that unanimous bearish consensus with squeeze-risk asymmetry demands immediate execution. Re-engagement requires TWO of four conditions (confirmed close >$317 with RSI >40, MACD positive cross, Fed-cut probability >50%, or 10Y below 4.5%/mortgages below 6.5%), with mandatory reassessment within 5-10 trading days of Q3 FY2026 earnings mid-November. Tactical short entry is only justified upon confirmed capitulation volume (≥9-10M shares) on close below $287.90.

Outcome

–

Return

+0.35%

Status

scored

Exit HD position to zero over the next 2-4 weeks. Trim 50-60% on any relief rally into the $302 zone with stops at $315 on residual exposure; execute the remaining 40-50% at market or on a confirmed daily close below $288.68 on volume ≥3M shares. No fresh short exposure pre-breakdown. Downside targets $260-275.

Outcome

✓

Return

-1.53%

Status

scored

Trim 50-60% of HD position over 2-4 weeks targeting 1.0-1.5% residual (down from >2%), using relief rallies toward 10 EMA (~$304) or 50 SMA (~$328) as better exit levels. Hard exit triggered at confirmed close below $285 on volume ≥3M shares. The unanimous bearish conviction across all analysts and the 9/17-9/18 binding lessons against half-measures require committed execution, while the institutional floor at $295-300 and 3.05% dividend on real $10.76B FCF warrant preserving a small residual rather than full exit.

Outcome

✗

Return

-2.83%

Status

scored

Maintain existing compressed HD position without adding or trimming into oversold; capture 3.14% dividend yield on $10.76B TTM FCF while awaiting Q3 FY27 earnings mid-November 2026. Hard binary exit at confirmed close below $290 on volume ≥3M shares; activated contingent trim trigger at confirmed close below $295 converting the 9/18 "activated but unfilled" architecture into actionable discipline. Tactical 15-20% trim into $314-$320 relief rallies toward Bollinger middle band/prior support.

Outcome

✗

Return

+2.74%

Status

scored

Sell at market (~$297.20) with full exit to size-to-zero per the 9/18 binding reflection's explicit guidance directing commitment at this tighter proximity zone ($297–298 inside the defense band). Unanimous bearish conviction across all three analysts converges with hostile macro conditions (Polymarket mortgage-to-7% at 88%, 10Y ~5%, recession odds 7.5%→17%), broken technical setup across all timeframes (death cross, RSI 28, MACD -8.98), and structural earnings erosion (4-year EPS decline 14.7%, operating margin compression 15.3%→12.7%). Re-engagement triggers: 2 of 4 conditions (one technical + one macro), with re-evaluation scheduled within 5-10 trading days of Q3 FY27 earnings mid-November 2026.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.93%

Status

scored

Maintain Underweight with the $295 confirmed-close trigger ACTIVATED as binding full exit — if $295 breaks on volume ≥3M shares, rating downgrades to Sell and residual goes to zero. Tighten rally-trim entries to $302-305 (2-3% from spot) rather than the rejected $310-320 level, with hard backstop at confirmed close <$289. Capture the 3.08% dividend on residual 65-75% core position while awaiting structural trigger delivery, with re-engagement requiring two of four macro/technical conditions to normalize.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.84%

Status

scored

Maintain compressed residual HD position (~0.5–1.0% NAV) while ACTIVATING the prior contingent trim trigger at $295 confirmed close with volume ≥3M shares as a binding FULL EXIT, converting to Sell. The lesson log is dispositive against fresh trim into oversold defended-floor tape, with hard backstop at confirmed close below $290. Re-engage only on TWO of four conditions (one technical + one macro), reassessing within 5-10 trading days of Q3 FY27 earnings mid-November 2026.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.01%

Status

scored

Analysts unanimously recommend HOLD on Home Depot, maintaining the compressed residual position (~0.5-1.0% NAV) rather than executing fresh adds or trims into the current setup. The three-analyst synthesis correctly identifies realistic asymmetry at ~1.5:1 (not the 8:1 cited by the aggressive view), with zero of three confirmation gates fired for re-engagement, while the institutional floor at $295-$300 and 3.05% dividend on $10.76B FCF provide near-term support. Hard exit is triggered at confirmed close <$285 with volume ≥3M, with re-evaluation scheduled within 5-10 trading days of Q3 FY26 earnings in mid-November.

Outcome

–

Return

-0.99%

Status

scored

Maintain HD at compressed residual (~0.5–1.0% NAV) under an UNDERWEIGHT rating; the bearish directional conviction is confirmed by death cross, MACD at -7.78, 10Y at 5%, and valuation risk (19x forward with recession scenario target of $240), but existing sizing already implements the Underweight view operationally. Hard binary exit triggered at confirmed close below $290 on volume ≥3M shares; contingent trim at confirmed close below $295 on volume per binding 9/04/9/08 discipline. Re-engagement requires any TWO of four conditions (technical and macro), preventing full exit that would forfeit the 2.97% dividend carry on $10.76B FCF and institutional floor optionality.

Outcome

✗

Return

-1.73%

Status

scored

Maintain the compressed residual HD position (~0.5–1.0% NAV) while explicitly not executing fresh trim into $320–325 rallies, as the trim-into-oversold-quality-name-tape failure mode has been empirically tested across five prior cycles. Hard exit is set at confirmed close <$289 with volume ≥3M shares, with dividend carry of 2.97% on $10.76B FCF preserved while awaiting Q3 FY27 earnings as the structural catalyst.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.69%

Status

scored

Maintain the existing compressed residual HD position at ~0.5–1.0% NAV (the Underweight directional bias is already captured through sizing); do not execute the trader's SELL or the Research Manager's 30–40% fresh trim into rallies as both replicate documented trim-into-oversold-tape failure modes from the lesson log. Hard exit at confirmed close below $289 with volume ≥4M shares, with a pre-committed contingent trim trigger at $295 with volume ≥3M shares per the 9/04/9/08 binding discipline, and re-engagement trigger at confirmed close above $317 with RSI >40 and volume. The 2.97% dividend carry on $10.76B real FCF provides yield extraction while awaiting Q3 FY27 earnings re-evaluation mid-November 2026.

Outcome

✓

Return

+1.00%

Status

scored

The analysts debated HD's HOLD rating, with the aggressive case for buy rejected due to miscalculated risk-reward (9.5% upside vs 3.9% downside, not 5:1) and the conservative case for underweight also rejected given the 2.97% dividend yield, $9.15B annual capital returns, and institutional floor at $295–$300. The decision is to maintain the compressed residual position (~0.5–1.0% NAV) and capture dividend income while awaiting structural trigger delivery—specifically Q3 FY27 earnings mid-November 2026, Fed cut probability shift above 50%, or technical breakout above $317 on volume.

Outcome

✓

Return

-1.53%

Status

scored

Maintain existing compressed residual HD position at ~0.5-1.0% NAV without executing fresh trim at $309.84, as the Underweight rating already reflects directional bias and already-compressed sizing. Hard stop is set at $289 on close with volume >4M shares, with a pre-committed contingent trim trigger at confirmed close <$295 with volume ≥3M shares. Re-engagement is triggered by confirmed close >$335 on volume >3M shares with MACD positive cross, with full re-evaluation within 5-10 trading days of Q3 FY27 earnings mid-November 2026.

Outcome

–

Return

-1.04%

Status

scored

Maintain the existing residual Underweight position at ~0.5-1.0% NAV from the cumulative 8/19-9/04 compression discipline, with NO fresh trim at the current $321 area despite the bearish directional view. Pre-commit a contingent trim trigger on confirmed close below $295 with volume ≥3M shares, with a hard stop at $289 on close above 4M shares volume.

Outcome

✓

Return

-2.29%

Status

scored

The analyst team unanimously recommends maintaining the existing Home Depot Underweight with no fresh trim at $321, despite acknowledging bearish macro conditions (93% no-cut probability on Polymarket, 1-year high mortgage rates, Lowe's DIY guidance cuts) and technical breakdown (sub-all-MA, MACD -1.94, RSI 40 not yet oversold). The 9/03 reflection is deemed dispositive: three prior cycles empirically demonstrated that trimming into oversold conditions with the $295-300 defended institutional floor and 2.93% dividend carry produced documented alpha costs ranging from -0.8% to -1.3%, making preemptive trim a replicated failure mode rather than disciplined risk management. The existing residual position already implements the bearish view at the low-end of defensible sizing, and the $289 hard stop with volume >4M shares provides the appropriate floor protection without forgoing the dividend carry and institutional floor optionality.

Outcome

✗

Return

+0.94%

Status

scored

Reduce HD exposure to 50-75% of benchmark weight over a 6-12 month tactical horizon given confirmed downtrend with expanding negative momentum (MACD -5.08), 23% drawdown, hostile macro (89% no-cut probability), and margin compression to 12.86%; execute first 25-33% reduction at market now since current price $318.07 is already below the trader's $327 entry target, stage remainder into any $327-340 relief bounce, and complete reduction on confirmed close below $307.50 with volume ≥3M shares using a $289 hard stop on residual core.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.14%

Status

scored

Maintain HD at compressed residual position (approximately 0.5-1.0% NAV) with diversified consumer-cyclical sleeve; reject aggressive add at $318 due to zero of three 8/11 confirmation catalysts firing (50 SMA at $340.14 still 6.8% above, MACD histogram at -2.65 most negative in sample, zero Polymarket Fed-cut probability), reject further trim due to binding 9/01 lesson (paid friction and dividend forfeiture for ~80bps alpha), and reject tactical starter as same failure mode in diluted form. Hard trim trigger: confirmed daily close <$295 on volume ≥3M shares; hard add trigger: confirmed close >$340 on volume >3M shares AND MACD positive cross. Price target $320 with re-evaluation within 5-10 trading days of Q3 FY27 earnings mid-November 2026.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.39%

Status

scored

Trim 50-60% of HD into the $332-340 relief bounce zone using limit orders (not market orders at $319.77), retaining 40-50% as core holding for dividend carry (2.84%) and tactical optionality, with a hard stop at $310 on the sold tranche if price closes below that level on volume >3M shares. Re-engagement requires any two of: confirmed close >$340 on volume >3M with MACD positive cross, Polymarket Fed-cut probability >50% for 2026, or two consecutive quarters of operating margin stabilization >12.7%; re-evaluate within 5-10 trading days of Q3 FY26 earnings mid-November 2026.

Outcome

✗

Return

-2.46%

Status

scored

Maintain HD at the low-end ~1.0-1.5% NAV residual per 8/19-8/27 trim discipline—do NOT execute fresh trim, tactical short, or additional put-spread/collar hedge. Hard stop is $325 on close with >3M shares volume confirmation; discretionary mental stop tightened to $322. Hold is superior to both the aggressive analyst's SELL and Research Manager's Underweight because the institutional floor at $325 has been validated twice, the catalyst calendar is empty until Q3 FY26 earnings, and cross-ticker 8/27 lessons converge that pre-event action on compressed R/R is alpha-destructive in rangebound setups.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.71%

Status

scored

Maintain Home Depot at the 1.0-1.5% NAV residual with no trim at $330-335 (replicates 8/21 failure), no fresh adds at $310-320 without MACD histogram turn positive OR 50 SMA reclaim on volume >3M shares, and no hedge re-engagement—the put-spread structure bled 30-50bps via theta when HD never tested the $327 trigger. Hard stop is $325 on close with >3M shares volume confirmation, with re-evaluation within 5-10 trading days of Q3 FY26 earnings mid-November 2026.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.48%

Status

scored

Maintain HD residual at ~1.0-1.5% NAV with a put-spread hedge (long $335 / short $320) on 50-75% of residual at open, replacing the failed symmetric collar; reject both the trader's SELL at $339/$347 stop and the Research Manager's Underweight with 30-50% fresh trim per prior lesson log. Hard stop $325 on close with volume >3M shares confirmation; re-evaluate within 5-10 trading days of HD Q3 FY26 earnings mid-November 2026.

Outcome

✗

Return

-1.86%

Status

scored

Maintain HD at the ~1.0-1.5% NAV residual produced by the 8/19-8/25 trim discipline, with mandatory same-day collar execution (long $325 put / short $360 call) on 50-75% of the residual at market open. Do NOT add fresh capital at $337.50, do NOT scale-in, and do NOT execute incremental trim—hard stop $325 on close with volume confirmation.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.90%

Status

scored

Maintain HD residual at ~1.0% NAV and execute cost-efficient collar (long $325 put / short $360 call) on 50-75% of the residual position immediately at the open; do not initiate fresh trim at $342-343 or execute the trader's short, as these replicate prior failure modes documented in the lesson log. Defer any fresh trim until confirmed daily close below $327 on >3M shares volume or relief rally above $348, with hard stop at $325 on close. Re-evaluate within 5-10 trading days of Q3 FY26 earnings mid-November 2026.

Outcome

–

Return

+0.13%

Status

scored

Maintain Home Depot at the low end of the calibrated range (~1.0% NAV), immediately executing a cost-efficient collar (long $325 put / short $360 call) on 50-75% of the residual position; do not initiate fresh trim at $343 (replicating the 8/21 failure), deferring until confirmed daily close below $327 on >3M shares volume or relief rally above $348. The directional bias is bearish given MACD deterioration (-1.39), Polymarket hawkish regime shift (+10.5pp in one week), and structural operating margin compression (14.48% → 10.07%), but outright sell escalation is disqualified by institutional floor and short-squeeze risk documented in the lesson log.

Outcome

–

Return

+0.54%

Status

scored

Reduce HD residual from ~1.5-1.7% NAV to ~1.0% NAV over 1-2 sessions and execute a cost-efficient collar (long $325 put / short $360 call, 50-75% of residual) immediately, with hard stop at $325 on close with volume >3M shares; defer tactical short overlay until confirmed daily close below $327 on >3M volume, as structural concerns (buyback cessation, margin compression, premium PEG) warrant low-end sizing per 8/19/8/20 lesson log.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.33%

Status

scored

Home Depot remains on HOLD with residual ~1.5-1.7% NAV (down from prior 1.7-2.0%), mandatory collar hedge (long $325 put / short $360 call) sized to 50-75% of residual, and hard stop at $325 on close with volume >3M shares; no tactical adds permitted until TWO re-engagement triggers fire (200 SMA reclaim at $343 with volume, MACD positive cross, RSI basing above 40, or Q3 FY26 EPS beat with guidance raise), while $327 break on volume triggers 25-33% trim.

Outcome

✗

Return

-2.85%

Status

scored

Maintain HD at ~1.7-2.0% NAV residual, neither adding at current levels nor trimming further. Hard stop $325 on close with volume confirmation; optional 50-75% collar hedge at 1-2% premium. Re-engagement triggers at $350 (small add), $358 (larger add), and $370 with positive MACD (full re-engagement). Re-evaluate within 5-10 trading days.

Outcome

✗

Return

+2.02%

Status

scored

Maintain Home Depot at the already-reduced residual position (~1.7-2.0% NAV) produced by prior trim discipline on 8/13 and 8/17. Neither the trader's SELL nor the Research Manager's UNDERWEIGHT is warranted—the cumulative trim already brings the position to Underweight-equivalent sizing, and additional trimming at this rangebound setup replicates the 8/12 overcommit failure mode that produced only -1.2% alpha. Use optional collar (long $325 put / short $360 call) for event protection into Lowe's earnings and Jackson Hole, with hard stop at $325 on volume confirmation.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.12%

Status

scored

Maintain Home Depot (HD) at reduced residual (~1.7-2.0% NAV) by executing a measured 10-15% pre-print trim ahead of Q2 binary catalyst, with hard stop $325 and optional collar hedge (long $325 put / short $360 call) sized to 50-75% of residual at 1-2% premium. The pre-print trim hardens the floor against the documented soft-floor failure mode, while preserving asymmetric upside on bullish catalyst resolution. Do not add until post-print reassessment within 5 trading days using three vectors: operating margin trajectory, guidance credibility under interim CFO McPhail, and CEO Decker status.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.29%

Status

scored

Maintain the existing HD residual position (~2.0-2.5% NAV post-8/13 trim) with a $334 hard closing stop, optional collar hedge (long $325 put / short $360 call at 1-2% premium), and no additions into the Q2 binary catalyst; collect 2.73% dividend as coupon. Reassess within 5 trading days of the Q2 print based on three vectors: operating margin trajectory, FY27 guidance credibility under interim CFO McPhail, and CEO status update.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.83%

Status

scored

Maintain HD at neutral weight with a 25-33% trim executed in 2-3 tranches at $348-355 resistance over the next 3-5 sessions, leaving a residual ~2.0-2.5% NAV position. Hard stop at $332 on close with volume, with optional collar hedge (long $325 put / short $360 call) sized to 50-75% of the residual. The position will be reassessed within 5 trading days of the Aug 18 Q2 FY27 earnings print.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.50%

Status

scored

Trim 35-45% of HD exposure (to residual 1.5-2.0% NAV) in tranches at $340-348 over 3-5 sessions, paired with a cost-efficient collar or put hedge on the residual; hard stop at $322 on elevated volume (>3M shares) into the Aug 18 binary catalyst.

Outcome

✗

Return

-3.12%

Status

scored

Maintain HD at neutral weight (~3.0-3.5% NAV) with a 15-20% trim recommended only if currently overweight (>3.5%) ahead of the Aug 18 binary event; no pre-print adds at $345-348 are permitted due to the 200 SMA at $344.28 being reclaimed on only ~10 days of light volume. Hard stop is set at $322, with post-earnings reload triggers at $359 on ≥3M shares (target $385-$400) for the bull case or $322-335 (floor $295) for the bear case, with reassessment required within 5 trading days of the print.

Outcome

✓

Return

+1.05%

Status

scored

Maintain HD at 3.0-3.5% NAV as Hold rather than Underweight because prior Hold calls at this setup produced +0.6% to +1.6% alpha while Underweight calls produced -0.9% to -1.3% alpha, and current constructive technicals (MACD 4.03, RSI 57.32, price above all major MAs with 50 SMA rising toward golden cross) are stronger than prior Hold setups. Hard stop at $325 is non-negotiable; optional hedge via $335 strike Aug/Sep puts sized to 25-50% of position with 1-2% premium cost. Aug 18 earnings is the binary catalyst warranting this re-evaluation window.

Outcome

✓

Return

-1.36%

Status

scored

Trim HD from 3-4% benchmark to 2.0% (50% reduction) as Q1 FY26 confirmed structural margin compression with operating margin down 100bps YoY to 11.9% despite 4.8% revenue growth, breaking the operating leverage narrative; the 2.0% sizing preserves upside optionality if HD breaks above $360 while providing meaningful protection on confirmed deterioration, with $334 stop and $355-365 execution zone capturing resistance rather than chasing spot price.

Outcome

✗

Return

+1.75%

Status

scored

Maintain HD at neutral weight with position bracketed between $333.54 support and $360 resistance; do not add into the $353.50 distribution-day rejection or trim into the constructive higher-low base. Hedge structural housing-turnover exposure via covered calls at $360 or XHB puts rather than reducing the underlying position.