UNP

Outcome

—

Return

—

Status

—

Subscribe to read

Outcome

—

Return

—

Status

—

Subscribe to read

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.05%

Status

scored

Maintain UNP at current sizing (~75-80% of model weight) as the HOLD decision is binding on timing discipline—negative MACD (-3.52), RSI below 50 (46.4), and baseline volume (1.47M) do not confirm a constructive reversal, while the Q3 earnings catalyst (October 22-24) creates binary exposure that asymmetric timing cannot resolve. Re-engagement requires either confirmed close above $288 on volume ≥2.5M with positive MACD cross, or successful $260-265 test with reversal candle and RSI positive divergence, with hard stop at $260 confirmed daily close.

Outcome

✗

Return

+1.28%

Status

scored

Maintain Union Pacific at 75-80% of model weight with a hard stop at $263 (200 SMA confirmed daily close). Do not add into the $268-274 zone despite the premium valuation (22.3x trailing, 19.3x forward, PEG 2.75) and broken 50 SMA at $288, as the asymmetric risk/reward (realistic downside 9-11% to $245-250 on 200 SMA break yields ~1.83:1) falls below the 3:1 minimum trigger. Q3 earnings in approximately 3 weeks is the binding binary catalyst; the existing 10/1 trim already implements the 9/25 empirical band, and further trimming would compound the overcalibration error the 9/23 lesson explicitly warned against.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.70%

Status

scored

Maintain Union Pacific at 75-80% of model weight despite Q2'26 inflection strength (+11.5% revenue, +31.8% OCF) because current valuation (22.4x trailing/19.5x forward P/E) and technical weakness (price below 10 EMA/50 SMA) create unfavorable risk/reward. The structural stop at $260 (200 SMA) remains thesis break level, with three-tiered re-engagement triggers: $278.50 close with MACD confirmation, successful $260-265 reversal test, or Q3'26 print with ≥+8% YoY revenue and ≥$1.4B FCF.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.16%

Status

scored

Maintain Underweight rating at 75-80% of model weight (approximately 15-20% below benchmark), with a hard stop at $260 on confirmed daily close below the 200 SMA at $263. The collar structure (selling calls $290-295, buying puts $255-260) becomes primary for full-exposure mandates, while the trader's proposed additional 25-50% trim and conservative analyst's HOLD at full benchmark weight are both rejected—the current sizing reflects the 9/25 empirical band and avoids repeating the 10/1 overcalibration error.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.44%

Status

scored

Maintain Underweight at 75-80% model weight through the Q3 earnings catalyst window. Do not add at $278 due to unresolved overhead supply ($279-$290), corrective technicals (price below 50 SMA, MACD negative at -4.87), and manufactured risk/reward math. Do not trim further—the 25% already executed represents the cumulative trim and the 10/1 reflection explicitly stated it was overcalibrated; further reduction would compound that error.

Outcome

✗

Return

+2.15%

Status

scored

Analyst consensus favors an Underweight rating with a 25% trim of UNP exposure into the $275-282 zone ahead of the binary Q3 earnings catalyst, retaining 75% of model weight to honor the intact 200 SMA structural floor at $262. A hard stop is set at confirmed daily close below $262, with re-engagement requiring either a 50 SMA reclaim at ~$290 with MACD positive cross, or a successful $260-265 test with reversal candle and RSI divergence.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.11%

Status

scored

Maintain UNP at 2-3% portfolio weight with a hard stop at $260 daily close (200 SMA structural line). Pre-commit to a mechanical 10-15% trim one week before Q3 earnings (mid-October) regardless of price, given bearish momentum signals (MACD histogram at -0.62, forward P/E 19.3 at 5-year range top) ahead of a binary catalyst — this captures earnings risk without over-engineering execution. Re-engagement requires daily close above $282 on volume ≥2.6M with MACD histogram contracting.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.74%

Status

scored

Maintain UNP at 100% of model weight with a HOLD rating. Pre-commit to a 10-15% calendar-based trim one week before Q3 2026 earnings (mid-October) regardless of price, with a hard stop at $260 daily close. Set alerts at $262 (200 SMA test) and $281 (Bollinger middle band), while avoiding additions above current levels or early trims before the calendar trigger.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.02%

Status

scored

Maintain UNP at approximately 100% of model weight on Hold rating given deteriorating technical stack (14 sessions below 50 SMA, widening negative MACD histogram, no RSI bullish divergence) and elevated valuation (forward P/E 19.3, PEG 2.72), while the intact 200 SMA at $261.88 and STB merger optionality provide structural floor support. Implement a partial collar or put-spread through Q4 earnings to monetize elevated implied vol and finance downside protection while preserving merger-catalyst exposure.

Outcome

✗

Return

+0.11%

Status

scored

Underweight rating with 15-20% trim (two tranches: 10% at current $273-275 levels, 10% mechanically one week pre-Q3 earnings) reduces exposure to 80-85% weight while preserving the structural floor argument anchored to the 200 SMA at $261.65, $6.45 dividend, 40% ROE, and probability-weighted STB merger optionality; a hard stop at $258 daily close protects against breakdown, while re-engagement triggers at $293 on volume ≥3M or successful $260-265 test with RSI positive divergence await better entry conditions post-catalyst.

Outcome

–

Return

-0.53%

Status

scored

Trim UNP exposure to 50–75% of model weight by executing into rallies at the $282–$290 resistance cluster (10 EMA, VWMA, 50 SMA confluence), while maintaining a hard daily-close stop at $260 (200 SMA structural line) on residual core positions; do not initiate new longs at current $275 levels, as the asymmetric risk/reward favors waiting for the $261–$267 reload zone (3.2–5.3:1 vs 2.3–4.3:1). Q3 earnings in late October serves as the binary reset catalyst that will re-anchor the thesis.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.41%

Status

scored

Union Pacific maintains a HOLD rating as execution-ready rather than passive retention, with existing holders instructed to trim 25-40% on any volume-confirmed rally into the $282-$293 resistance cluster. New positions are gated by two triggers—successful $261 retest with bullish divergence or volume-confirmed reclaim of $280—each sized at 2-3% up to a 5% total cap, with hard stops at $255 daily close and $258 weekly invalidation. The Q3 earnings catalyst in 3-4 weeks, expanding MACD at -5.19, and untested 200 SMA at $261 make this an active trim discipline rather than passive hold.

Outcome

✗

Return

+1.77%

Status

scored

Maintain UNP at current weight with active trim discipline rather than passive retention—trim 25-40% of existing positions into the $282-$293 resistance cluster on volume confirmation. Do not initiate new longs until either a successful test of $260 with reversal candle and RSI divergence, or volume-confirmed reclaim of $282. Tactical shorts permitted at <0.5% equity into $282-$285 with stops above $295. Q3 earnings in mid-October serves as the binding revalidation checkpoint, with eight independent deterioration signals currently present including RSI 24.56, MACD widening negative, and lower Bollinger tag on elevated volume.

Outcome

✗

Return

-3.49%

Status

scored

All three risk analysts, the Research Manager, and the Trader converge unanimously on HOLD — directional verdict is unanimous. The technical setup shows real momentum deterioration (RSI 32.54 without positive divergence, MACD widening lower every session since 9/04, price below 10/EMA, 50-SMA, and Bollinger mid), but the 200-SMA at $260.58, $6.45 dividend carry, 39.7% ROE, and probability-weighted STB merger optionality justify retention over Underweight. The HOLD must be paired with aggressive trim-on-break trigger discipline rather than passive patience.

Outcome

✗

Return

-1.10%

Status

scored

Maintain UNP at neutral weight with unanimous Hold verdict across analysts. Two recent Underweight calls (9/15, 9/16) produced negative alpha as UNP never approached the $278 invalidation and the 200 SMA absorbed every selloff. Structural alpha from $6.45/share dividend carry, 40% operating margin, and STB merger optionality ($6-12/share) justifies patience, but momentum deterioration (10 EMA rolled for 11 sessions, MACD histogram expanding bearish, price below all short/medium MAs) and compounded probability requirements for the aggressive analyst's upside case prevent upgrade. Stop anchored at $273.41 (lower Bollinger Band ~2 ATR daily close), with trim triggers requiring confirmed technical reversal signals, not price-zone entry alone.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.56%

Status

scored

Maintain UNP at current calibrated position size (~50-55% of benchmark weight) with HOLD rating; the 5-way directional consensus converges on Hold despite debate on framing and stop levels. The structural stop remains at $258 on weekly close (below 200 SMA at $260.04), rejecting the Conservative Analyst's proposed $272 stop which contradicts the $258-268 add zone. Hedge the residual with 3-5% $280-strike puts; wait for confirmation triggers including 200 SMA test with RSI/MACD divergence, buyback resumption at $500M+/quarter, or Q3 fuel cost absorption.

Outcome

–

Return

-1.08%

Status

scored

Trim ~45% of UNP via two-stage execution: ~25% immediately at $284 for execution certainty, then ~20% into any relief bounce at $288–$292. Retain ~55% residual with $278 daily-close stop and 3–5% put hedge at $280 strike, avoiding the trader's $276 stop (too wide) and conservative's $282 (too tight). Re-engage on daily close above $293.65 with volume ≥3M and flattening MACD, or capitulation flush to $258–$265 with volume ≥4M.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.38%

Status

scored

Maintain Union Pacific at 50-55% benchmark weight with 3-5% $280-strike put protection (correcting the 9/10 alpha leakage from 7-10% ATR sizing), using $278.36 closing-basis stop as invalidation. Trim 25-30% of residual only on confirmed technical reversal into $296-302 zone (bearish engulfing, MACD negative cross, or failed $300 retest required). Reject the Aggressive Analyst's Add call due to 1:1而非不对称的 risk-reward math, improper 200 SMA treatment, and momentum deterioration signals; reject further trimming per BLK cross-ticker calibration (200 SMA intact). Primary re-evaluation at Q3 earnings (late October); full exit below $259.14 weekly close.

Outcome

–

Return

+0.24%

Status

scored

Trim 40-45% of UNP at $280-285 while retaining a hedged core at ≤50% benchmark weight with 3-5% puts (not 7-10% ATR-sized), closing-basis stop at $279.41, and no fresh longs above $280 until re-engagement triggers fire at $250-260 (200 SMA test, capitulation volume ≥4M) or Fed dovish pivot.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.48%

Status

scored

Maintain UNP at current calibrated size (post-9/9 trim) with no incremental buying or trimming at $285, as the 5-way HOLD consensus (Research Manager, Trader, all three risk analysts) is binding per the 8/31 lesson. Add only on confirmed weakness to $265-$272 with half-size position and $256 stop, or full-size with widened stop ($248-$252); trim 20-25% into $293-$298 rallies. The $280-strike put hedge at 7-10% of position neutralizes ATR-expanded regime risk per the 9/1 lesson, converting the HOLD from passive alpha-negative drift into alpha-neutral positioning through the STB catalyst window extending to late 2027.

Outcome

✗

Return

+0.37%

Status

scored

Trim UNP 40-45% given five stacked negatives—broken 50 SMA with expanding negative MACD, hawkish macro headwinds (0% cut probability), full valuation at ~20x P/E, merger regulatory overhang (STB timeline extending to 2027), and asymmetric risk-reward of 26% downside versus 8% upside—while retaining a residual core position because the 200 SMA structural floor at $258.48 remains intact and full exit would forfeit ~$6.45/share in dividend carry plus merger optionality. Hedge residual with 7-10% put protection at $280 December strike given live binary catalysts (Sept 16 FOMC, STB procedural calendar).

Outcome

✗

Return

-1.29%

Status

scored

Maintain UNP at its existing calibrated size with no incremental buying or trimming at $288.45. The structural franchise and rising 200 SMA near $258 support continued ownership, but Q2 margin contraction, deteriorating momentum, reduced buybacks, and premium valuation make a fresh add premature.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.40%

Status

scored

Maintain Union Pacific at 55-65% benchmark weight on three-analyst HOLD consensus; deploy no fresh capital until a daily close above $295.89 on volume exceeding 3M with MACD histogram stabilizing or turning positive. Address the live ATR-expanded regime and binary STB catalyst risk via $280-strike puts sized at 7-10% of position or alternatively widen the hard stop from $275 to $268; apply an explicit alpha-budget clock requiring technical confirmation within 5-7 sessions or automatic reassessment to Underweight.

Outcome

✗

Return

+0.16%

Status

scored

Trim to neutral weight at ~$289 via staged execution (~40% now, ~40% on bounce to $297-$302 resistance, ~20% retained as core), with a tighter stop at $302-$304 instead of the trader's $310. Re-engagement requires either a daily close above $302 with MACD positive and RSI reclaiming 50, or a flush to $265-$270 with RSI ≤30 on expanding volume ≥4M. Hard invalidation levels at $284, $287, and $257 on volume confirm full exit triggers.

Outcome

✗

Return

-0.20%

Status

scored

Maintain Overweight on UNP but override the trader's proposed $282.50 entry today—the binding 8/31 lesson requires MACD confirmation rather than price-only entry, especially given the expanded ATR (6.59 vs. June's compressed levels) and prior alpha drag (-2.7% on 8/31, -0.7% on 9/1). Total exposure capped at 1.5-2.0% with staged adds conditioned on MACD histogram flattening/positive plus price stability above $285 with declining volume, a flush to $272-276 with bullish reversal, or a confirmed close above $300 with improving momentum; hard stop remains at $266.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.31%

Status

scored

Union Pacific earns a HOLD rating at 55-65% benchmark weight, with no fresh capital deployed at $290.62 due to unfavorable 2:1 risk/reward against a one-ATR stop, and no further trimming given three prior calibrations have already captured available premium. A tiered fresh-capital framework awaits technical confirmation (price stability above $285, RSI >35, MACD histogram positive/flattening from -1.05) before deploying 50% standard allocation, with hard invalidation levels at $284 (trim 25-33%), $287 (full exit), and $257 (thesis invalidation).

Outcome

✗

Return

-3.34%

Status

scored

Maintain Union Pacific at 55-65% of benchmark weight, with no additions above $304 given unfavorable risk/reward versus waiting for the $290 (50 SMA) add zone. The position is already calibrated from three prior trims, and momentum deterioration (MACD histogram down 96% in six weeks, distribution signature on elevated volume) warrants a confirmation-based approach rather than preemptive scaling. A 3-5% put hedge at $285 strike with 3-6 month tenor manages merger-decision tail risk while the structural thesis (39.7% ROE, $61B irreplaceable PP&E, STB optionality at $310-330) compounds through the 6-12 month regulatory window.

Outcome

✓

Return

-2.19%

Status

scored

Maintain Underweight with a 5-10% incremental trim at the lower bound of guidance, executed in tranches (~40% at $310-312, ~60% at $313-314), targeting residual position of 55-65% benchmark weight with $290 closing-basis stop and ~2% portfolio risk sizing. The position preserves dividend carry (~$6.45/share through STB window) and merger optionality ($6-12/share probability-weighted) while trimming into strength rather than full exit, with re-engagement triggers at $280-289 pullback, $316 breakout above 4M volume, or positive STB procedural milestone.

Outcome

–

Return

-0.08%

Status

scored

Maintain Underweight on UNP with a measured 10-15% incremental trim executed in tranches (~40% at $307-308, ~60% into $310-312), rejecting both the Aggressive/Conservative analyst overcorrection and the trader's $316.50 stop as structurally flawed; preserve the asymmetric structure through the 2.2% dividend yield and merger optionality in the 50-55% conditional-approval bucket while honoring prior reflection guidance to default to lower bounds when neutral-drift M&A regimes underperform expected drawdowns.

Outcome

–

Return

-0.95%

Status

scored

Execute a measured 10-15% incremental trim of the UNP position through staged limit orders in the $311-315 zone, retaining approximately 85-90% of post-8/20 calibration, calibrated between the Research Manager's aggressive 25-33% proposal and the trader's full-Sell framing. The $316 stop is cancelled as consensus-rejected (sub-ATR and functionally a buyback instruction), with re-entry to occur only in tranches after support is tested, MACD stabilizes, and the 10 EMA flattens or turns higher—rejection of arbitrary price-level buying.

Outcome

–

Return

+0.33%

Status

scored

Union Pacific (UNP) is upgraded to Overweight with a disciplined staged-entry framework: initial tranche sized at 55-65% of maximum conviction at $297-303 pullback (20 SMA/Bollinger midline), not at $309.59 spot, with hard stop at $287 and primary target $315-320. The 6-9 month holding period through the STB BNSF-NS merger ruling (post-May 2027) captures the confirmed structural uptrend while respecting the binary catalyst risk and premium valuation that justified prior Hold decisions.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.09%

Status

scored

Hold Union Pacific at 65-70% benchmark weight given unfavorable risk/reward at current $310 price (~$14 upside to $325 vs $24 downside to $287). The position is correctly calibrated after prior trims, and fresh capital should only be deployed on pullback to $302 (10 EMA) or $287 (50 SMA). A fourth trim would push into over-correction territory, while adding at $310 fails the asymmetric test with binary STB catalyst risk layered on top.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.59%

Status

scored

Hold Union Pacific at 65-70% of benchmark weight, as the stock is too strong for further trimming but lacks favorable risk-reward to add at current levels ($308). The position has a hard stop at a daily close below $300 on volume, and fresh exposure is deferred until either a pullback to $280-285 with RSI below 50, a Q3 2026 beat-and-raise, or a materially favorable STB procedural milestone.

Outcome

✗

Return

+1.34%

Status

scored

Maintain Underweight with a measured 10-15% incremental trim (smaller than the Research Manager's 20-30% proposal) given that two prior trims already calibrated the position at 75-80% benchmark weight, and the 8/10 lesson warns against over-correction in neutral-drift M&A regimes. Execute into strength above $300 over 2-3 sessions. Hard stop at $284 (just below 50 SMA at $285.40). Re-engagement only on confirmed breakout above $315 on 6M+ volume, OR pullback into $285-296 with constructive macro/merger catalysts. Probability-weighted price target clusters near $295.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.72%

Status

scored

Maintain UNP at 75-80% of benchmark weight, collecting the 2.2% dividend through the STB ruling. Do not add at current levels ($301.80) given the stock is within 4.5% of the 52-week high on a setup that remains coiled rather than confirmed; EPS growth (+6.7%) lagging revenue growth (+9.9%) and MACD at -62% off its July 24 peak signal deceleration rather than a healthy reset.

Outcome

✓

Return

+1.02%

Status

scored

Maintain 75-80% of post-8/17 benchmark weight at ~$298 (do not add or further trim). Stop loss sits at $280 daily close (volume confirmed). Re-engagement requires either a confirmed close above $307.32 with volume >3M plus MACD positive and RSI >55, or a pullback to $275-287 with RSI >45 and MACD bottoming. Probability-weighted price target clusters near $295 with a 6-9 month timeline through the STB ruling and Q3 2026 earnings checkpoint in October.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.39%

Status

scored

Trim approximately 20% of the UNP position into the $295-300 zone over 2-3 sessions while retaining a 75-80% core holding, with a hard stop at $280 on the remaining position; re-add triggers include confirmed close above $304.30 on volume >3M shares with MACD histogram turning positive and RSI >55, or pullback to $253-265 zone near the 200 SMA. The $295 price target reflects a 6-9 month timeline through the STB ruling, with expected return slightly below current levels when factoring in credible patient-capital opposition to the BNSF merger.

Outcome

✗

Return

+2.12%

Status

scored

Execute a measured 20% trim of UNP into the $293-295 zone over 2-3 sessions while retaining 75-80% core holding for franchise quality (39.7% ROE, 2.2% dividend yield) and merger optionality; set hard stop at $280.00 daily close, defer hedging until post-STB ruling when IV compresses, and reassess on momentum breakout above $303.84 or pullback to $282-290 with RSI confirming support.

Outcome

✓

Return

-1.38%

Status

scored

Maintain core UNP position at Hold; do not add at $297.79 given stretched multiple and binary STB overhang. Trim 10-15% (reduced from trader's 25-33% blanket) only on confirmed close above $304.69 with RSI >55 and MACD histogram turning positive. Re-engagement zone refined to $282-290 with hard invalidation below $280 (tightened from flawed $282.20 stop), replacing the $270 anchor. Collect the 2.2% dividend yield through the 6-9 month STB timeline.

Outcome

✓

Return

+1.38%

Status

scored

Maintain UNP core position at current levels with no additions at $293.73 given full valuation and binary STB overhang; collect the 2.2% dividend through the 6-9 month timeline. Trim only 10-15% (not the trader's 25-33%) on confirmed close above $300 with RSI re-accelerating above 55 AND MACD histogram turning positive, preserving 85-90% of position to capture merger optionality. Re-engagement zone revised to $285-290 with hard invalidation below $280; tighter stop replaces the prior $268 anchor that created 14% drawdown before reaction.

Outcome

✓

Return

+0.29%

Status

scored

Maintain core UNP position at Hold as structural franchise quality (39.7% ROE, 40% operating margins, 11.5% revenue growth) is offset by top-decile valuation (23.7x P/E, 8.95x P/B), six-week MACD momentum decay, and binary Berkshire-backed regulatory risk on the $71.5B BNSF merger. Execute only a 10% trim on confirmed close above $300 with RSI >55 and positive MACD histogram, preserving 90% of the position for merger optionality. Hard stop tightened to $280 (50 SMA break), with add-zone at $285-290 and 6-9 month timeline to STB ruling.

Outcome

–

Return

+0.22%

Status

scored

Analysts recommend trimming 25% of UNP holdings targeting 50-75% of model weight, citing four aligned bearish technical signals (MACD cross, lower high at $307, RSI rolled to 52.85, price below VWMA) and a 97% collapse in buybacks from $959M to $26M, while acknowledging the prior UNP Underweight produced only -0.3% alpha due to neutral drift. Execute sells into rallies toward $297.24 (VWMA) or $293.89 (10 EMA), with hard stop at $280.33 and optional 6-9 month $270-280 puts as convexity insurance against STB denial.

Outcome

✓

Return

-0.30%

Status

scored

Execute a measured 25-33% trim in UNP targeting 70% of benchmark weight, selling rallies into the $300-305 zone, with a hard stop at $278 (50 SMA break). Re-enter on a daily close above $295 with RSI re-accelerating above 55 and MACD histogram turning positive—avoid mechanical bounces off $278. Layer 6-9 month $260-270 puts as cheap convexity insurance against the STB denial tail risk over the 6-9 month horizon.